TB Evaluation defined:
In one view, we can define textbook evaluation as matching the materials with the goals of language teaching in Iranian context.
Review of Literature
A few people have attempted to evaluate the present English textbooks in Iranian schools:
Ansary and Babii(2002)
Manuchehri (1971)
Yarmohammadi (2002)
Riyazi (2010)
In the introduction, there are some questions to be dealt with first.
1- The goal of language teaching in Iran: Is it to develop oral skills or written skills?
2- What are the subcomponents of the skill to be taught?
3- How can we achieve these objectives?
There are many and different checklists to evaluate textbooks. Some are mentioned below:
1-Chastain, K. (1971). The Development of Modern Language Skills: Theory to practice (pp. 376-384). Philadelphia. The Center for Curriculum Development, Inc.
2-Tucker, C. A. (1975). Evaluating Beginning Textbooks. English Teaching Forum, 13, 355-361.
3-Cowles, H. (1976). Textbook, Materials Evaluation: A comprehensive checksheet. Foreign Language Annals, 9 (4), 300-303.
4-Daoud, A. & Celce-Murcia, M. (1979). Selecting and Evaluating a Textbook. In M. Celce-Murcia and L. McIntosh (Eds.), Teaching English as a second or foreign language (pp. 302-307).Cambridge, MA: Newbury House Publishers.
5-Candlin, C.N. & Breen, M.P. (1979). Evaluating, Adapting and Innovating Language Teaching Materials. In C. Yorio, K. Perkins and J. Schacter (Eds.) On TESOL '79: The learner in focus (pp. 86-108). Washington, D.C.: Teachers of English to Speakers of Other Languages.
6-Rivers, W. (1981). Teaching Foreign-Language Skills (pp. 475-483). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
7-Williams, D. (1983). Developing Criteria for Textbook Evaluation. ELT Journal, 37(2), 251-255.
8-Sheldon, L. (1988). Evaluating ELT Textbooks and Materials. ELT Journal, 42 (4), 237-246.
9-Skierso, A. (1991). Textbook Selection and Evaluation. In M. Celce-Murcia (Ed.), Teaching English as a second or foreign language (pp. 432-453). Boston, MA: Heinle & Heinle Publishers.
10-Ur, P. (1996). A Course in Language Teaching: Practice & Theory (pp. 184-187). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11-Kilickaya , F .(2006) . Guidelines to evaluate cultural content in textbook
The Internet TESL Journal .Retrieved April 25, 2006 from http: // itself .org
/Techniques / kilickaya –cultural content.
12- Finocchiaro, M and Bonomo, M (1973) The Foreign Language Learner (pp 256-259)
New York: Regents Publishing Company, Inc.
I have chosen first Abdel-Messih Dauod and Marianne Celce- Murcia's and then Kilackaya's checklists to evaluate the current English textbooks used in Iranian high schools.
1-Textbook Evaluation Checklist (Abdel-Messih Dauod and Maianne Celce- Murcia's)
A. Content
i. Is the subject matter presented either topically or functionally in a
logical, organized manner?
ii. Does the content serve as a window into learning about the target
language culture (American, British, etc.)?
iii. Are the reading selections authentic pieces of language?
iv. Compared to texts for native speakers, does the content contain
real-life issues that challenge the reader to think critically about
his/her world view?
v. Are the text selections representative of the variety of literary
genres, and do they contain multiple sentence structures?
B. Vocabulary and Grammar
i. Are the grammar rules presented in a logical manner and in
increasing order of difficulty
ii. Are the new vocabulary words presented in a variety of ways ?
iii. Are the new vocabulary words presented at an appropriate rate
so that the text is understandable and so that students are able to
retain new vocabulary?
iv. Are the new vocabulary words repeated in subsequent lessons to
reinforce their meaning and use?
v. Are students taught top-down techniques for learning new
vocabulary words?
C. Exercises and Activities
i. Are there interactive and task-based activities that require
students to use new vocabulary to communicate?
ii. Do instructions in the textbook tell students to read for
comprehension?
iii. Are top-down and bottom-up reading strategies used?
iv. Do the activities facilitate students’ use of grammar rules by
creating situations in which these rules are needed?
v. Does the text make comprehension easier by addressing one
new concept at a time instead of multiple new concepts?
vi. Do the exercises promote critical thinking of the text?
D. Attractiveness of the Text and Physical Make-up
i. Is the cover of the book appealing?
ii. Is the visual imagery of high aesthetic quality?
iii. Are the illustrations simple enough and close enough to the text
that they add to its meaning rather than detracting from it? iv. Is the text interesting enough that students will enjoy reading it?
2- Kilackaya's checklist
Very few scholars have given the cultural dimension of EFL full coverage . One of these scholars is Ferit Kilickaya who has published a paper in the Internet TESL titled " Guidelines to evaluate Cultural Content in Textbooks " . In this paper he attracts the reader's attention to the factors involved in cultural content i.e. socio-cultural , learners' needs , teachers' role , the nature of materials with emphasis on hidden curriculum , stereotypes and generalizations .
The items which Kilackaya has included in the guidelines stress the following :
A) The textbook itself :
- Does it give instructions to the teacher about how to use it , and how to handle the cultural content?
- Does it address specific learners?
- Does it suggest any role to the teachers ?
B) The cultural information presented in the book :
- Does it include a variety of cultures or just specific one i.e. British or American culture ?
- Is it taken from the author's own ideas or different sources ?
- Is the reality of the target culture represented ? or Does it represent the author's view ?
- Is it culturally suitable for the learners in class ?
C) Illustrations :
- Are there illustrations ?
- Are they appropriate to the learner's native culture ?
- Are the illustrations clear or do they need additional information ?
D) Activities :
- What are the activities asked of the learners ?
- Are the activities familiar to the learners ?
- Are the activities familiar to the teacher ? or Would the teachers using this book and its activities need specialized training ?
- Is there enough information given to the teacher as how to use such activities ?
- Are the learners asked to be aware of the cultural information presented in the activities , for better understanding of the target culture or using it actively ?












